Any ideas?

So do you think it’s stretched or something? Cause the proportions aren’t the same (see “P”).
Or is the sample pre-digital, so that nothing we find will be exactly identical?

Nina, your sample of Archive Antique Extended looks very close, except for the tracking.
Another candidate is the old FontBank “Hefty”
- Mike Yanega
Captured from web.archive.org on 10 May 2009. view this capture