Can be wrong but as pointed out, this looks too much symmetric to be a font to me, more a hand-lettering. The apparent effort to make strokes equally thickened is weird too. They may even have started with strokes, creating the sans backbone then adding serifs. You could also try to rework Trajan, cutting and mirroring some strokes.
Some alternatives: Penumbra (Half) Serif, Monkton, Weiss, Jupiter, Giovanni

Ryuk, seems like you could be right. Either this, or they mirrored some existing characters.. I've looked at the alternatives you suggested and will try to put something together based on these. (I have to produce additional letters to an existing text).

Thanks for the help!