I think this is more recent than eary 1900.

JESUS ONLY style may be matched by Univers Condensed Bold.

The type in the logo seems hand made.

The small type style may be matched by Univers Extended.

The sample is too small to discern.

The creator of the logo died in 1931...so, not likely that it's recent. I have that Univers Condensed font but I'm not actually seeing the same comparison you've made. Thank you!