Life is short. Stay awake for it.
If you're looking for this logo type it's not Agency, but I don't recognize it.
Sounds like the font you're looking for is in their ads which don't play on the east coast.
Based on this thread, I'm not gonna be drinking any of their coffee. However, this report is 2 years old and they may have changed investors since then.
Update (and I don't know why I bother since I've never even heard of this Caribou Coffee) according to this report the company is still 88% owned by a Muslim bank which endorses Shariah. However the anti-Israel sheikh is no longer affiliated with the bank.
Found this on google image search. The slogan is definitely Agency.
- Lex
It's quite possibly a custom font, since hand-printed styles can be done as cheaply as free. If it's a commercial or common freeware font there's a good chance it is shown in Part 11 of the Script Font ID Guide. Be prepared to search through about 25 web pages.
Picnic is close if you don't need an exact match.
Here you go: Regular Joe of Art Parts fame, as Tiffany correctly identified.
Another that's similar is Litterbox
http://www.fonts.com/findfonts/detail.asp?pid=405855
I think it's agency.
[link]
Captured from web.archive.org on 1 Nov 2010. view this capture