Anyone have an idea what this font might be? Thanks in advance for your help!

This is hand-lettered, look at the spikes.
You could start with DS Kork if you look for something similar. BTW Blackletter and ALL CAPS is EVIL.
Happy Halloween!
Andreas
You could also have a look to Hydro74 fonts, there are probably one that could do the job.
Captured from web.archive.org on 16 Jun 2017. view this capture