I think this may be the same as the other font, just not squooshed. And my previous guess of Caslon Antique doesn’t work, since the ’Q’ is different.

- Lex

I’m sure there’s an actual better font of this.. so far all I had found was this free one from da font that is somewhat similar.. I’m assuming this Roman Antique is probably based off of whatever is in your sample.
http://www.dafont.com/font.php?file=roman_antique&page=1&nb_ppp_old=10&t...

Kris Todd
Graphic Designer
www.kasinkris.com
Twitter: @KasinKris

If the poster is this:
http://www.cinemasterpieces.com/screamjan08.jpg
the roughness is just compression artifacts.

Yes, same as the top: Adobe Garamond.