It seems the slab serif font is called "Archer" and the serif font is "Surveyor" both created by Tobias Frere-Jones (http://www.typography.com/) for Barbara de Wilde, the former art director of Martha Stewart Living. Surveyor (which must be the italics on this cover) is based on old map fonts. See this article.
I couldn't find font showings for either, though. Maybe now that Martha's a bit hard up she'll sell these fonts to us peons to raise some cash.
Captured from web.archive.org on 3 Dec 2006. view this capture