Does anyone know of a good connecting script that is similar in feel to this hand?
Or is Typo Upright, which doesn’t seem to connect reliably, my best choice?

Ah but typo upright is so... yuck, and that is so nice. Consider:
http://www.mvbfonts.com/html/fonts/chanson/pk_chanson.htm
or Batarde Coulée from Lineto.com (their site is flash so no linking)... here's a screen shot:

@Randy:
Thanks, and re Typo Upright, agreed: “Ah but typo upright is so... yuck...”, but I am hoping to find:
• An upright script that’s similar to the sample
• One that’s not artificially “distressed”, the sample is low-res and thus somewhat “antique-y”, but the original, from the FDR library, is clean
I hope someone here has more suggestions, thanks.
their site is flash so no linking
@Randy:
No Flash involved, actually – just nasty frames.
http://lineto.com/The+Fonts/Font+Categories/Historic+Fonts/Batarde+Coulée/
This is sort of a hybrid. Part Chancery and part secretary hand. Might want to check out all the offerings listed as Civilite, they are not connecting and probably more refined than you want. Also Operina would be an alternative. Dont think you are going to get what you want but you might make the ballpark : )
Michael
Agedage Cancelleresca from Flat-It might be worth a look.
Captured from web.archive.org on 16 Oct 2013. view this capture