This seems really similar to Palatino, but there are differences. Anyone know what this font is? Thanks!

Aldus looks close, but the bold weight changes the E, so not sure.
p@
I don't think it's very old. It's part of a logo for a local rock products company. I'm not sure how long they've been around. I have a hard time believing a company like that would have custom lettering in their logo, but I guess anything is possible. I ended up redrawing the letters using the sample above, and I used Palatino Bold for the subcopy.
Captured from web.archive.org on 19 Oct 2013. view this capture