Any typophiles out there with a suggestion for another typeface that is similar to this one?

I'm having a hard time committing to this one-- it's ALMOST working, but I'm interested in trying out a few substitutes...
Many thanks!
Thanks, Jackie- I think you're right about it being Agency Open, though it's showing up in my library as AgencyGothic Plain.
At any rate, here is the context (the version with Agency is third from the left; all are still in the "puttering around" phase.

it's for a wedding photographer's website. Her style is cute and a little quirky, but also sophisticated and cosmopolitan.
HA!
I know- I noticed how PRONOUNCED that word was when I returned to my desk after lunch, and I was like, "WHOOPS!" That's kind of the problem with that font- it got to that point because it only looks good big (when it's smaller, it contorts and degrades on screen thanks in part to the shadow, methinks. Thanks so much for the feedback, all- when I have it a little more nailed down I'll come back for a full critique (yes, I know, there were about 50 more double-entendres in this paragraph. Get back to work, you perverts!)
Captured from web.archive.org on 22 Jun 2013. view this capture