I would guess this is custom-made. It may have been inspired by the most famous face of our good friend F.W. Goudy, though.

I’d say this is a chopped up Century Schoolbook:

It’s possible this actually exists as a freeware font somewhere.

Yves, how responsible that suggestion is. It adds a warming tone to the request much like a soothing suntan.

I’m not sure about this particular incarnation, but the “Sing the Sorrow” packaging and accompanying logo with the orig AFI characters were done by the guys at Morning Breath. http://www.morningbreathinc.com

Thanks for all the responses! I think I’m going to have to hang around this board more often, as I’m definitely learning something.

Thanks also to Christian for the link. Oh goodie, a prospective employer.