Typophile

Least Favourite Letters

Bendy

This is a funny question, perhaps.
What are people’s least favourite letters to design when starting a font? Do they get left until last, or do you get them out of the way first? Are they the ones that are simple or complicated?
I’ve only started on one family but it seems my least favourites are left until last in all of the weights. I think I don’t like the ones that seem like their shapes can withstand less experimentation (like M, V or Y), or are similar to other shapes (P or Q), and love the freedom of experimentation with complicated curvy shapes (like a, g, e, s). I like designing x too.
I find number glyphs the hardest, but that’s probably because in my daily life I am subjected to more letters than numbers so they are more familiar.
Does anyone else find the same thing?

Gosh! I forgot to mention o and O...they are very deceptive. To a novice they seem simple, but there’s a lot of things going on in that ellipse that need to be right. There isn’t the freedom...either it’s right or it’s wrong.

I struggle with x (and X). It’s a stealthy bugger. It’s a relatively simple beast to start with, but if it needs adjusting its simple demeanour hides a complex and time-consuming beast. Getting the optical compensation on the bottom-left to top-right stroke is a bugger to adjust if you need to flesh it out or slim it a bit. It being at the end of the alphabet doesn’t help either. You think you’re nearly there with your adjustments and x takes you an hour. The bastard!

oO0 are all a bit trecherous, but that’s probably down to the fact they are so fundamental. I mean, an o is primary, wheras an h falls out of an n.

8 is a toughie too. But an enjoyable one. 4’s a stiff beast. 2 is quite gratifying. I like the numbers in general. As Jonathan Hoefler pointed out in a talk recently, their open sides are (mainly) opposite to the Roman alphabet: They open to the left. When you get on to them it makes for a refreshing change.

I like g though. g’s a pleasure. Nicer than G, which I often have trouble disconnecting from the C. s & S are good too. Complex is often satisfying. Z, though simple, always comes out easily. It seems to sit more solidly than most. Sitting it back on its haunches is satisfying. I like the fact it’s ’backwards’ too — thick stroke on the ’wrong’ diagonal.

Captured from web.archive.org on 9 Jul 2008. view this capture