Typophile

Anti-aliased Vs. Aliased type for HTML type in screenshots?? Help..

lorem ipsum factor

Hello everyone, Ive a problem which im not sure whether this is the right place or not, but i thought i’d throw it out there to see what people on here thought on the matter..

Right then, just so you know, Ive professionally been designing for screen based medias for 10+ years now and whenever ive done designs in the past, for say a new web site, ive always set the text in Photoshop that i intend to display as HTML type to ’aliased’ (or ’non anti-aliased’ to those that wrongly refer to it). This has been so that the client (and any other coder/designer picking up this project at a later date) can clearly see a distinction between the use of images and HTML type. I know that presenting a flattened .jpg this way is a massive presumption that the client will have < IE6 since that browser cant render HTML type as anti-alias but it is, for now, still the majority browser... so this is where my problem lies.

I had my boss come to me the other day complaining that the screen shot i had sent him for prior approval (copy errors etc) wasnt ’the best ever we could visually provide the client’... I was sat there with my anti-aliasing HTML Mac trying to explain the hows and whys of my actions before finding a PC with IE6 to demonstrate my point. I also had to state that his new laptop was running Vista/IE7 and it anti-aliases the type and thats why other websites on his screen looked really nice, compared to the printed out ’aliased’ HTML type version i had designed in his hand. I also pointed out that the low client expectation level is covered this way, and should the client have IE7 not IE 6 upon its HTML build then it will only look better than what i originally delivered as a flat .jpg screenshot.

and no, my boss isnt an art director, nor a senior designer type, hes the top level management company type boss so you know.

So anyway, my predicament is: should i start to anti-alias all my HTML example text in photoshop cos of IE7 now anti-aliasing? or stay designing the way i do??

any thoughts, advice or similar experiences please

Captured from web.archive.org on 7 Oct 2008. view this capture