Stymie 1 and/or 2
http://www.veer.com/products/typedetail.aspx?image=EFT0000384
http://www.veer.com/products/typedetail.aspx?image=EFT0000383

Candida is one of my favourites
http://www.veer.com/products/typedetail.aspx?image=ADT0003231

Hedonic (might be a little too modern and different, perhaps not blocky enough — and the letter m bothers me but what the heck!)
http://www.p22.com/ihof/hedonic.html

That Veer redraw of the venerable old Stymie is quite nice! Thanks for the link Andi!

ChrisL

Maybe not as bleeding-edge as Cholla -- and I do like Cholla -- but you could look at Dispatch from Font Bureau.

Nice suggestions so far. Serifa is a little less rigid than Stymie and better for text.
Maybe it's too obvious, but ITC Officina might be right here.

Hey, what about Joanna ?

could you not just adjust the "e" to your liking? If that is the typeface you like and are having trouble finding one that can be an alternative... seems like the easiest thing to do.

PMN Caecilia is my favorite.

--------------
nc