You could try other slab serifs like Rockwell or Memphis .

Oddly enough, for what you may be looking for, there is a whole category called "Old School" at Dafont.com

WOW! What a collection!

Except look at all the "categories" they classify the typefaces under:

Groovy, Destroy, Trash, Sexy!
How are we to help ID typefaces when the vendors don't even know what to call their collections?

----------------------------------------
Yes, I'm old, but I'm Groovy Trashy!

Hoboken High Slab Serif from Lineto.

Ben, when I saw the sample, my thoughts also went immediately to Hoboken High, but it would have to be customized - for instance, the stroke is thicker, the point on the "M" comes to a complete vertex in the center, and the serifs on the "E" and "F" characters are longer than in Hoboken. My guess is that this is a very generic and not-all-too-hard-to-make custom display that happens to resemble Hoboken.