In the Baskerville family, not sure which though.

The serifs are more pronounced on all the Baskervilles I've looked at. Any other thoughts?

It feels like Goudy

It isn't Goudy -

Evan, can you give us the source of your sample?

a scan from a business card. I looked at the website and it is nothing like the Chicago Title logo type. Maybe it was typeset by some quick printer using some "free" font or knock-off. I did not recognize it and thought maybe someone else has seen it before.

The engraving process might also have softened the serifs.

Despite not having the spurs on the T, I think it looks like some flavor of Garamond.