How about:

I'm working on a logo for a band, based on this antique 19th-century book cover I found.

And so far it's going better than I thought it would. This is a screengrab from illustrator:

Looking for advice on what I have so far, and on turning this "P" into an "R". Does anyone know of a typeface that's similar in form I could look at for reference?
If I get better at this I might try and go for a full typeface, rather than just a 9-letter logo, but at the moment I'm not so sure...
| Attachment | Size |
|---|---|
| pennsylvania-illustrated2.jpg | 139.67 KB |
| pennsylvania-illustrated-P.gif | 14.69 KB |
How about:

Bojev, thanks so much for taking the time to make that! I would never have thought of that kind of leg. Super helpful.
I really like yours, and this is the one I just made before I saw your post... now I can't decide which style to go with...

That second leg looks great! Assuming the letter is supposed to be going "uphill".
The first one has a certain oriental feel.
hhp
Thanks hrant, it's definitely supposed to be going uphill (see original image above)
I've been staring at it for so long, I was starting to get worried that it looked terrible and I just couldn't tell. Having another pair of eyes on it helps tremendously.
I still love bojev's option and I'm torn, but I feel pretty confident to move on to the rest of the letters for now. I'll definitely post more when I have more.
Maybe combine a bit from each - I like the terminal on yours.
bojev - I like that idea. Going to try it when I get the other letters done and see.
quick update:

Only 3 letters left to go! These will have thinner stripes in the hollow parts. Hoping I can get away with the cheap way I did it on the R.
I was super worried about drawing on a curve, (instead of on a straight line and arc-ing the whole thing later) but I'm really pleased with how it's going!
Finished design. I can't decide whether to keep the flags or not. Thanks to all of you for your insights, may be revisiting this tomorrow but I'm done for the night.

Captured from commoncrawl.org on 26 Apr 2015. original URL