Matt, I think the nature of low-res printers is such that any type you print often comes out a little heavier than it would be coming out of an imagesetter, though there are different versions of Times/Times New Roman out there.
Even before I posted I tried the Times New Roman on my machine which looked a bit heavier than the sample above. Maybe I have a poor version of that typeface. I'll check it again.
I wasn't printing... the final art will be for the web. The preview didn't look close... again it looked real heavy but I may have inadvertently had some text settings that changed the weight.
I'll have to check it out tonight on my home computer.