I'm the art director for a small theater company whose unofficial motto is "theater for people who hate theater; theater for people who love theater."
Our audience, for the most part, ranges from 18-35, not your typical theatergoing crowd. Here is the logo, plus some recent poster images, to give you an idea of the kind of work we do:
Now, the request: I want to select a typeface (with both display and text weights) that reflects the company's attitude. Show logos will always vary, but I want to keep the information font the same from poster to poster (other design elements will also help create a consistent look among posters).
In addition, I want the typeface to be appropriate for text usage, such as for the program. Two faces I've considered are HTF Gotham and PsyOps Faceplate Sans, but neither seems to really fit the bill.
Any suggestions will be quite helpful.