not that it "matches" but Chicago has similarities in some of the characters. emphasis on "some."

edit: and this one's interesting.
http://www.myfonts.com/fonts/smeltery/vernissage/

My selection (Italic could be done by shearing Regular): Kirsty (Serifs Needing To Be Removed - SNTBR), Brothers (SNTBR), Heretic (SNTBR), Dime Box (SNTBR), Slinger (compressed), Concave Tuscan, Vintage Gothic, Concave Tuscan X, Gothic Tuscan, Mineesota, Teniers (SNTBR)

Thanks for the suggestions! I really appreciate it.